Self-Publishing Mistakes: 10 Lessons from Indie Authors

“Mistakes are proof that you’re trying—and trying is how every successful author starts.” — Joanna Penn

Learn from the common pitfalls new indie authors face. By discovering how to sidestep costly mistakes, you can save time and build a stronger publishing foundation from day one. The best lessons often come from others’ experiences.

Every indie author makes mistakes. It’s part of the learning process. But some self-publishing mistakes are so common (and costly) that avoiding them can save you weeks of frustration and hundreds of dollars. The key is to be aware of these pitfalls and steer clear of them.

The good news? You don’t have to learn everything the hard way.

In this part of our series on self-publishing, we highlight the biggest self-publishing mistakes new authors make and how to avoid them. These are not just random tips, but valuable lessons shared by real indie authors who turned setbacks into success. Pay attention, as these insights can make a significant difference in your publishing journey.

Mistake #1: Publishing Too Soon

It’s exciting to finish your first draft and want to share it with the world, but hitting “Publish” too soon is one of the most common regrets among new authors. A rushed book often includes:

• Typos and formatting errors
• Weak cover design
• Unclear or unpolished structure

Solution: To avoid these self-publishing mistakes, slow down. Invest time in editing, formatting, and building your launch plan. Think of publishing not as a sprint, but as a marathon. The better prepared you are, the more professional your book will look and the stronger your first impression.

Mistake #2: Skipping Professional Editing

Even the best writers can’t catch all their own self-publishing mistakes. Self-editing helps, but professional eyes are essential. Common issues editors catch include:

• Inconsistent character details or pacing
• Grammar and punctuation errors
• Awkward dialogue or repetition
• Missing logic or structure gaps

Solution: Use free editing tools (such as our favorites: Grammarly or ProWritingAid) first. Then hire a professional for line or copy editing. If your budget is tight, consider a manuscript critique or beta readers before your final edit.

Mistake #3: Underestimating the Importance of a Good Cover

Readers do judge a book by its cover, especially when they’re shopping online. An amateur cover can kill sales, no matter how good the writing inside. Here are common cover mistakes:

• Poor typography or clashing fonts
• Misaligned genre design (e.g., a thriller cover that looks like romance)
• Low-resolution images

Solution: Research your genre’s top-selling covers. Use professional design tools like Canva Pro, Book Brush, or hire a designer on Fiverr or Reedsy. Your cover should instantly communicate genre, tone, and professionalism.

Mistake #4: Neglecting the Book Description

Your book description is more than a summary. The description is your sales pitch. Many authors write bland blurbs that fail to capture readers’ interest. Common blurb problems include:

• Too much plot, not enough intrigue
• No emotional pull or clear benefit for the reader
• Generic openings that don’t stand out

Solution: Think like a marketer. Lead with tension or a question. Use short paragraphs and a clear call to action. For non-fiction, highlight the reader’s problem and how your book solves it.

Mistake #5: Ignoring Formatting and Interior Design

A messy layout screams “amateur.” Poor margins, inconsistent fonts, and awkward chapter breaks can distract readers even if the story is great.

Solution: Use tools like Atticus, Reedsy Book Editor, or Vellum for clean, professional formatting. Always preview your eBook and print editions before publishing.

Mistake #6: Failing to Build an Author Platform Early

Many authors publish their book first, then start thinking about marketing. That’s backwards. Without an audience, even great books struggle to find traction.

Solution: Start building your platform months before launch.

• Create an author website.
• Set up social profiles.
• Start an email list with a free reader magnet.
  A small, engaged audience is preferable to a large, indifferent one.

Mistake #7: Pricing Your Book Incorrectly

New authors often price too high or too low. If it’s too high, readers may skip your book in favor of established authors. If the price is too low, you undervalue your work or lose money after printing costs.

Solution: Study similar titles in your genre. Most indie eBooks perform best between $2.99 and $4.99. Paperbacks should be both competitive and profitable (calculate print costs using Amazon’s KDP pricing tool).

Mistake #8: Ignoring Keywords and Categories

Amazon is a search engine first and a bookstore second. Many new authors skip keyword research—and their books vanish in the crowd.

Solution: Use all seven keyword slots and choose the most relevant categories for maximum visibility. Tools like Publisher Rocket can help you rank higher and attract more organic traffic.

Mistake #9: Expecting Overnight Success

Publishing your book is an achievement, but it’s not the finish line. Many authors grow discouraged when sales don’t soar immediately.

Solution: Think long-term. Consistency builds credibility. Keep writing, marketing, and learning. Each book builds on the visibility of the ones before it.

Mistake #10: Trying to Do Everything Alone

Self-publishing doesn’t mean solo publishing. When you try to handle every detail (editing, design, marketing, and ads), you risk burnout and lower quality.

Solution: Seek help where needed. Join author communities, hire freelancers for specialized tasks, and collaborate with others. The indie author community is one of the most generous out there.

Real-Life Lesson from New Indie Authors

“I thought publishing was the hard part. It wasn’t. It was learning how to market and connect with readers. Once I stopped doing everything alone and started networking with other authors, everything changed.” — Angela M., Romance Author

 Lesson: Treat your author career like a team effort. Success accelerates when you learn from others’ experiences.

Wrap Up

Every author makes mistakes, but each one is a stepping stone to growth. The beauty of self-publishing is that you can fix, relaunch, and improve at any time. What matters most isn’t about perfection. What matters most is persistence. The grit not to quit.

Learn from those who’ve gone before you, focus on quality and connection, and you’ll build a long-term career that grows stronger with every release.

Checklist: Avoid These Common Self-Publishing Mistakes

• Don’t publish before editing and formatting are complete
• Hire or trade with a professional editor
• Invest in a genre-appropriate cover design
• Write a compelling book description
• Format for both eBook and print editions
• Build your author platform before launch
• Research pricing, keywords, and categories
• Manage realistic expectations: focus on steady growth
• Collaborate and learn from other indie authors

We hope you’ve found the writer’s guide strategies helpful and motivating. We hope they’ll equip you with the insights and tools needed to help you succeed as a new author.

For more guidance, see other writer’s guides in the series, such as Amazon KDP Made Easy—7 Steps for Self-Publishing. You might also like AI Empowers New Indie Authors: 5 Best Hacks.

Writing is a journey of continuous learning and improvement. You don’t have to go it alone. We’re excited to continue the journey with you, providing guidance and encouragement every step of the way. Our goal is to provide essential insights and practical advice to help you navigate the writing world with increased confidence.

If you have a draft you want to publish and are wondering how AI can help, read it. Is Your Book Ready to Self-Publish? Lastly, for help writing a non-fiction book, read Write Your First Non-Fiction eBook: a 30-Day Workbook for Getting It Done.

Don’t wait. Start today!

How can we help? To let us know, please fill out our Contact form. Happy writing!